Issue:
HB-4657, the so-called “bonding over” proposal, would seriously weaken the mechanics lien rights of contractors, subcontractors, laborers and material suppliers that the construction industry has fought hard to secure.
Often times, the only leverage available to a contractor who is owed money for work performed is to record a mechanics lien against a project. Property owners are more interested in paying for the work done on the property if there is a mechanics lien that they must cause to be released at the insistence of their bank or other parties. Without a mechanics lien on the property, contractors and subcontractors, especially smaller and minority firms are compelled to either accept a significantly smaller payment for their work, or endure expensive and lengthy litigation. When an owner retains a substantial payment owed a small subcontractor, the playing field is not level in the ensuing game to recover payment. Often, the only counter lever is to record a mechanics lien. If a bond could easily replace a lien, the leverage available to encourage fair payment would be lost.
Further, a “bonded over” lien does not guarantee the contractor will be paid in full for work completed. Once title on a property is cleared – the property can then be sold. If a contractor filed a lien that was “bonded over” the only available option is to hire an attorney and seek payment from the surety. The surety’s objective is to negotiate for a lesser dollar amount. This proposal requires the contractor to obtain legal counsel to object to the bond if it is inadequate and make the argument to the court – placing the burden of proof upon the contractor.
Solution:
We are asking for your support and a “no” vote on HB 4657. This bill will further damage an already stunted construction industry in Illinois. Mechanic’s liens are the only assurance a contractor has to ensure payment on work completed. Allowing bonds to stand in the place of mechanic’s liens will remove the ability of contractors to receive full and timely payments for work and materials supplied.
HB 4657 can be found on the Illinois General Assembly’s website here:
http://www.bit.ly/1ftT17d
By James T. Rohlfing
http://www.rolaw.net